Kingstone Companies (KINS) is a New York-focused personal lines property-casualty insurer. As of March 31, 2026, total assets were $465.3M against total liabilities of $350.8M, leaving GAAP book equity of $114.5M. Under a liquidation lens, recovery to equity is heavily constrained by the nature of the liability stack and the composition of the asset base. The dominant liability is loss and LAE reserves ($171.7M gross, $120.3M net of reinsurance recoverable), which do not extinguish on windup and are carried at face/undiscounted actuarial estimates. Unearned premiums of $153.6M are a further runoff liability with no corresponding asset premium — these obligations survive a stop-writing scenario. Together, reserves plus unearned premiums exceed $325M gross, representing the core liquidation exposure. On the asset side, the investment portfolio is the primary source of recoverable value: AFS fixed-maturity securities at fair value of $293.8M (amortized cost $304.1M, net unrealized loss of $10.3M), HTM securities at amortized cost $6.0M (fair value $5.1M), equity securities at fair value $9.8M (cost $13.5M with $3.7M gross unrealized loss), and other investments (hedge fund) at $3.8M. Under liquidation haircut assumptions, AFS bonds are already marked to fair value and would likely achieve close to that in an orderly runoff sale given predominantly investment-grade ratings (97%+ rated BBB- or above). The hedge fund ($3.8M) would face meaningful illiquidity haircut given lock-up and redemption constraints — filing does not separately disclose redemption terms. Cash of $11.4M recovers at par. Reinsurance recoverables of $58.0M are a significant asset but subject to counterparty credit risk and commutation discount in a liquidation — filing does not separately disclose counterparty credit quality of reinsurers. PP&E of $8.0M would receive a 50-70% haircut. Deferred policy acquisition costs of $27.8M and deferred tax assets of $6.3M (with $3.5M valuation allowance already applied) are zero-recovery intangible items in liquidation. Operating loss carryforwards of $53.6M have no standalone liquidation value. The Holding Company's dividend receiving capacity from KICO is currently zero per DFS restriction — a critical structural constraint. KICO paid a $1.8M dividend to the Holding Company in Q1 2026 but has no further capacity without DFS approval. The Holding Company also funded a new subsidiary KAIC with $5.1M in Q1 2026, a cash outflow with no near-term dividend return. Q1 2026 generated a consolidated net loss of $5.8M driven by an 81.6% net loss ratio, which included a 26.0 percentage point catastrophe load from eleven Northeast winter events. Operating cash flow declined to $8.7M from $17.9M in Q1 2025. A material weakness in internal controls related to SOC 1 reports for the premium quoting platform and general ledger system remains unremediated as of the filing date, with remediation targeted for December 31, 2026. The MFFAIS CLV/LLV/OLV figure of $7.1M is far below GAAP book equity, consistent with the liquidation lens penalizing illiquid, haircut, or zero-value assets against face-value liabilities including the $153.6M unearned premium reserve and $171.7M loss reserve stack.
▼ Community Notes